Report 1 — released spring 2014

monitoring poverty
and well-being
in new york city

Experts have long pointed out that deep-seated flaws in the way the federal government calculates poverty distort our picture of life at the bottom of the economy.
A first-of-its-kind survey conducted by Robin Hood and Columbia University’s Population Research Center reports that poverty in New York City extends further than official federal statistics suggest. The Poverty Tracker measures income poverty, severe material hardship, and severe health challenges to capture the dynamics of poverty and distress in New York City. These numbers reveal a far grimmer story than the official measure indicates.

How do the official
measures work today? d

uIntroduction

THE OFFICIAL POVERTY MEASURE IS WRONG

The federal government developed the Official Poverty Measure (OPM) in the 1960s, and it doesn’t reflect the massive changes to the American family over the past 50 years. The Official measure is based solely on minimum income level needed to afford food and meet daily needs. Yet the measure doesn’t account for the rising costs of living expenses, the geographic variation in costs of living, or the full spectrum of income sources families use to meet daily needs.

How many New Yorkers
are actually in poverty?d

uThe OPM

NEARLY ONE IN FOUR NEW YORKERS FACE INCOME POVERTY

The federal government recently introduced the Supplemental Poverty Measure. It is also based on income, but it incorporates the expenses of basic living necessities — food, shelter, clothing and utilities, the geographic variation in living costs, and it adjusts for the variety of factors that impact income to include government benefits and tax credits. The Poverty Tracker used the SPM methodology and found that more than 1.9 million people in New York City are living in poverty.

What if income doesn’t
capture the whole story? d

u Income Hardship

37% OF NEW YORKERS
SUFFER SEVERE
MATERIAL HARDSHIPS

In 2012 nearly four of ten New Yorkers faced a persistent shortage of critical resources or underwent an episode of acute deprivation, such as staying in a shelter, having utilities shut off or being unable to pay for a doctor.

Material hardships
Financial
Food
Utilities
Housing
Medical
?
x
hint
Toggle the left buttons on and off to see the percentage of New Yorkers who suffered each type of severe material hardship. In its default setting, the chart represents adults who experienced any of the five types of hardship.

How is health tied to scarce
financial and material resources? d

u Material Hardship

HEALTH CHALLENGES ARE MORE PREVALENT FOR THOSE UNDER THE POVERTY LINE

While people may suffer from health and related challenges regardless of their economic situation, indicators of well-being are often tied to poverty and material hardship. The numbers of New Yorkers reporting poor health or a severe work-limiting health condition increases under the poverty line.

How many New Yorkers experience multiple
forms of disadvantage at a time? d

uHealth Challenges

MORE THAN HALF OF NEW YORKERS FACE AT LEAST ONE DISADVANTAGE

53% of city residents struggled with income poverty, severe material hardship, or health-related challenges in 2012. Nearly one in five New Yorkers experienced two types of disadvantage simultaneously. 4% experienced all three disadvantages.

income
Hardship
Health

What happens next?d

u Dimensions of disadvantage

This study is just the beginning.

The statistics reported here are the first of many reports that will allow us to measure the well-being of New York City residents. Future surveys will gather more detailed information on the health and well-being of respondents and their children, various shocks to respondents’ homes and family lives, holdings of assets and debts, experiences with city government and social services, and many other topics. Though the content of these reports can be disconcerting, we’re confident that our in-depth, multi-layered tracking will be an important, positive step in addressing the underlying causes of poverty and ways to devise more effective programs to help New Yorkers in need.

Coming soon

DISADVANTAGE, HEALTH, AND WELL-BEING AMONG NEW YORK CITY’S CHILDREN

A closer look at New York City’s children and an examination of how New Yorkers do – and do not – get their needs met by services provided by government and social service agencies.

The Columbia Population Research Center integrates a wide range of research disciplines in the effort to promote the health and well-being of vulnerable populations.

learn more r


Robin Hood is New York’s largest poverty-fighting organization, and since 1988 has focused on finding, funding, and creating programs and schools that generate meaningful results for families in New York’s poorest neighborhoods.

learn more r